The relationship between taxpayer and revenue authority is undergoing rapid, fundamental transformation. Tax compliance has always been retrospective: the taxpayer collects data, completes computations and submits returns months later; the authority reviews those submissions and decides whether to enquire. That is changing.
Tax compliance is being re-engineered to operate alongside new systems of commerce characterised by 'live' transactions and the centralisation of data and processes. Tax has ceased to be a discrete, back-office, after-the-event reporting function; it is a continuous, increasingly automated presence in commercial operations and critical to business decision-making.
This change has been underway for years, driven by digitalisation and businesses searching for greater efficiency and commercial advantage. Tax authorities have had to respond, both to secure their own efficiencies and to obtain the data they need to assess compliance and protect national revenue. The introduction of artificial intelligence (AI) will see the pace of change accelerate.
For those involved in M&A activity, the shift raises practical questions including:
- How robust is a target's digital tax infrastructure?
- At what point does a deficiency in a target's tax technology become a material issue affecting valuation?
- How does a buyer obtain comfort on the accuracy and sufficiency of a target's digitalised tax data?
- How will a newly acquired business rank under a tax authority's algorithmic risk-assessment system?
- Does a transaction result in an increased risk of challenge or dispute with a tax authority?
- How should warranty and indemnity provisions reflect these emerging risks?
- How will the role of AI in tax affect the tax insurance market?
According to the OECD, more than 70% of advanced tax administrations are deploying AI in enforcement. HMRC is investing heavily to be a leader in adopting and scaling AI. A company's operations, arrangements and structures are increasingly visible to authorities worldwide. It used to be the case that HMRC operated in 'silos'; they found it difficult to align administration across different departments dealing with different parts of the tax system. That has been changing in recent years, but AI allows tax authorities to interrogate the vast amount of data available it collects, flagging weakness and inconsistencies.
A company's tax risk profile will increasingly be shaped by the quality of its data and its systems' ability to gather, process and report them. In addition, the expanding information-gathering powers of HMRC, allied with AI, make genuinely real-time reporting (RTI) a realistic prospect.
