More generous limits for Enterprise Management Incentives
The standout announcement in the Autumn Budget (from a share plan perspective) was the increase in many of the limits that apply to Enterprise Management Incentives. EMI is a particularly attractive form of share option plan for growth companies as it can offer tax relief and be tailored to deliver the desired incentive and reward. Unlike other forms of tax-advantaged share incentive, an EMI option does not have to be held for a set period to receive favourable tax treatment on exercise.
Although suitable for companies in the early stages of growth, one of the limitations of EMI has been that as a company begins to scale-up, it can soon cease to qualify for the grant of further EMI options. In recognition of this, the government has announced that from 6 April 2026, the aggregate value of EMI options a qualifying company can grant under an EMI plan will double from £3m to £6m and the gross asset limit for a qualifying company (or group of companies), will increase fourfold from its current level of £30m to £120m. Growing companies often have an expanding workforce so companies will welcome the news that the number of full-time equivalent employees that can be employed by a qualifying company (or group of companies) will rise from fewer than 250 to fewer than 500. Note that the individual limit for qualifying EMI options remains at £250,000 and the often overlooked 3-year limit continues to apply.
Under the current rules, to benefit from income tax relief, an EMI option must be exercised within 10 years of the date of grant. This 10-year window can prove too short for exit-based EMI options (that are exercisable on a sale or IPO of the company) or where participants wish to exercise only when they are able to sell their shares to pay the purchase price due. In another welcome move, the government has announced that the window for exercising an EMI option in tax-advantaged circumstances will increase to 15 years from April. As well as applying to options granted on or after 6 April, legislation is being introduced that will make it possible to amend existing options (that haven't been exercised or lapsed) to extend this exercise window without prejudicing their tax-advantaged status. Companies wishing to take up this opportunity will need to ensure that they follow the precise terms of the legislation once it is enacted.
To ease the administration of EMI plans (and bring them in line with other employee share incentives) the requirement to separately notify the grant of EMI options will be removed but not until April 2027. Until then, it is important to report the grant of EMI options as usual and even when the change takes effect, it will still be necessary to register the plan with HMRC and submit annual returns.
All these changes will give more businesses (including more AIM companies) the chance to offer EMI options to their employees which is very good news. However, companies that have received investment from financial sponsors such as venture capital, private equity backed funds and family offices often find that they are unable to meet the EMI requirements due to the way such funding is typically structured. The Travers Smith Incentives team will raise this issue in its response to the government's call for evidence on how the tax system can better support entrepreneurial activity in the UK.
For our analysis of the Autumn Budget 2025, please read our briefing here:
Autumn Budget 2025 | Travers Smith
Tax-advantaged share plans - time for a health-check?
As well as EMI, there are three other tax-advantaged share plans available. Two of these, Save As You Earn (SAYE) and Share Incentive Plans (SIP), must be operated on an all-employee basis whereas awards under Company Share Option Plans (CSOP) can, like EMI, be made on a selective basis.
The government has published the long-awaited response to a call for evidence on SAYE and SIP seeking views and evidence on the use of the schemes and whether they are achieving their policy objectives. Of the changes suggested by those responding (including the Travers Smith team), one of the most common was a call for the SIP holding period (currently 5 years) to be reduced to 3 or even 2 years to better reflect modern working practices. Although the government has not yet committed to make any changes as a result of the call for evidence, it has acknowledged the points made by those responding - an encouraging sign for the future of these important plans.
In the meantime, if you already have a tax-advantaged plan or are considering adopting a new share plan, it is worth looking to see whether you are making full use of the tax and NICs savings they can offer. For example, under a SIP, free shares with a value of up to £3,600 per annum can be gifted to employees without a charge to income tax and employee and employer's NICs. If employees remain in the business and their shares are held in the SIP for a minimum of 5 years, they can then be sold completely tax, NICs and capital gains tax free. From this April, the ordinary and upper rates of tax on dividend income will increase by 2% from 8.75% to 10.75% and from 33.75% to 35.75% respectively (there will be no change to the dividend additional rate of 39.35%). Under a SIP, dividends paid on plan shares can be used to purchase additional dividend shares that will enjoy relief from income tax and NICs if they are held within the SIP for at least three years.
If you haven’t used your CSOP for a while, remember that the limit on the value of shares that an individual can hold as tax-advantaged options under the plan is £60,000 (increased from £30,000 back in 2023) and there is no overall limit on how many CSOP options companies can grant (other than dilution limits imposed by companies themselves – discussed below).
Is your share plan getting close to its expiry date? Listed company plans will usually have a 10-year life in accordance with best practice, but the anniversary can come around surprisingly quickly. Check to see whether you need to seek shareholder approval to extend your plan at this year's AGM. Under the current Investment Association guidelines, all-employee plans no longer need a 10-year life. If you have a SAYE or SIP, you might want to consider amending it to remove the expiry date (subject to any feedback from your investors). For CSOP and other discretionary plans, it is worth remembering that the Investment Association guidelines no longer recommend a 5% dilution limit on the number of shares that can be issued in any ten-year period. Although the 10% in ten-year dilution limit for employee plans remains in place, the guidance recognises that in high-growth, newly listed companies, there may be a case to seek shareholder approval for higher dilution limits that go above this.
Preparing for a PISCES trading event
If you are a private company, consider amending your plans to provide an exercise window for a PISCES trading event. PISCES is a new type of secondary trading platform that allows for the intermittent trading of private company shares and may offer participants in private company share plans an opportunity to realise their investment in the company even where there is no traditional exit (such as a sale or flotation) in prospect. Note that it will be possible to amend EMI and CSOP options granted before 5 April 2028 to allow exercise on a PISCES trading event without a loss of their tax advantages. The amendment must require the option shares to be sold on the PISCES "as soon as reasonably practicable" following exercise and has to either be agreed by the parties in writing or notified to the participant in writing.
Share plans and leavers – the importance of process
When an individual's employment ends, the impact this will have on their share incentive awards will generally be governed by the relevant plan rules. These might cover a variety of situations depending on the circumstances of the employee's departure.
For example, someone considered to be a "good leaver" might be able to keep their awards for a period of time after employment, whereas a bad leaver might lose them. Quite often, to give companies the maximum amount of flexibility, the grantor will have the discretion to decide whether (and to what extent) a leaver can keep their awards.
In a group situation, practical difficulties can arise where the employer of the leaver negotiating the terms of any exit is different to the entity that granted the option and, accordingly, has the power to exercise any discretion. A recent case has shown that, in certain circumstances, the UK courts are willing to uphold an individual's claim to share awards where they were assured that they could keep them even though the process set out in the plan rules was not followed. It is easy to see how this can happen, and the case stresses the importance of employers and grantors communicating over leavers and ensuring that the procedure in the plan rules has been followed, clearly documented and notified to administrators.
On the subject of leavers, listed companies should note that proxy voting firm, Institutional Shareholder Services (ISS) has amended its guidelines by adding an explicit expectation that companies provide clear reasons and justification for treating departing executive directors as a good leaver under the terms of a share plan.
Share plans and leavers – the new Employment Rights Act
Companies could face other employment costs following the recent enactment of the Employment Rights Act 2025. The new Act introduces changes (due to take effect from January 2027) to employees' unfair dismissal rights, including (i) a reduction of the two-year qualifying service requirement for unfair dismissal claims to six months and (ii) a measure to remove the cap on such claims. Currently compensation for unfair dismissal is capped at the lower of one year's pay and £118,223, and removal of the cap will mean that there is no limit on the amount that can be awarded for unfair dismissal (this is already the case for discrimination and whistleblowing claims). For more information about the Employment Rights Act, please see the article published by our colleagues in the Travers Smith Employment team:
Employment Rights Act What does it mean for employers? | Travers Smith
When an employee leaves a business, they are often restricted in terms on their ability to work for other entities under what are known as "non-compete" clauses. In the Autumn Budget, over concerns that such provisions restrict employee movement and can discourage innovation, the government published a consultation working paper on ways of reforming non-competes in employment contracts. The options considered include the possibility of a complete ban on them or limiting the length of time that they can apply. Variations of this include the possibility of different limits for employers according to their size or only banning non-competes below a salary threshold. This is the resurrection of a proposal made by the Conservative government in 2023 but never introduced and it will be interesting to see whether the current administration takes it forward.
Share plan annual returns – it’s never too early to start!
No update would be complete without a reminder about annual share plan returns. Although the deadline for registering and sending returns in respect of share plans operated in the current tax year is still some way off (July 6), it is always a good idea to prepare early and make sure you have all the information you need when the time comes. If, sadly, an option holder has died, HMRC has recently confirmed that no reporting obligations arise on (i) the transfer of the option to the individual's personal representatives, (ii) the exercise of the option and acquisition of shares by them or (iii) the transfer of shares by the personal representatives to beneficiaries.
The HMRC guidance stresses that before submitting a share plan notification or return, you should save a copy of it for your own records, for example, by taking screen shots of each page, including the confirmation page. This is because the online service will not save the details and you will not be able to access them again once the return has been submitted. We will be sending out a reminder of the registration and annual return process following the end of the tax year but in the meantime, guidance can be found on the government website: Employment related securities: detailed information - GOV.UK.