The government has confirmed that it will proceed with all seven of its proposals contained in HMRC's Modernising the taxation of distributions and repayments of capital from companies consultation.
The changes are expected to take effect from April 2028 following a technical consultation on the draft legislation commencing in 2027.
We discussed the background and policy justifications for these proposals in a special mini-series of our Tax Focus podcast covering the Consultation. You can listen to the episodes here: Tax Focus podcast: Income or capital? HMRC's consultation on modernising the distributions framework | Travers Smith
The key personal taxation implications are set out below:
- Changes to the treatment of share buybacks and capital rebasing
The government intends to pursue its proposal to combat avoidance involving corporate reorganisations designed to increase the amount of share capital that can be returned to individual shareholders on a share buyback in a form that attracts (the lower rates of) CGT.
The proposal involves "freezing" the capital element by reference to the amount that was initially subscribed for the shares, so that the amount subject to CGT on any future buyback or reduction reflects only the amount paid on issue of the shares, rather than any additional share capital created under corporate law as a result of a later reorganisation.
The UK's rules already work in a different way to many jurisdictions by taxing amounts received on a buyback in excess of the share capital returned as an income distribution, and these changes are likely to increase the "income" element of the return on certain buybacks, create further disincentives for individual shareholders to dispose of shares in this way.
- New loans to participators charges for loans from non-UK close companies
Individuals who receive loans from non-UK 'close' companies (broadly, companies controlled by five or fewer participators) will be subject to a 'loans to participators' charge.
Non-UK companies have historically been outside the scope of the 'loans to participators' rules (provided that they do not fall foul of the extensive scope of the anti-avoidance rules related to such loans) and the rules applicable to UK companies place the burden for accounting for tax on the lender company (rather than the individual borrower), so the proposal to levy the charge on individuals in these circumstances is a significant change.
Whilst the government, in its response to the consultation, has indicated that it is open to proposals to limit the charge to those with a 'material interest' and to exclude loans made for 'genuine commercial purposes', as we have highlighted in our podcast discussions, the changes have the potential to create significant compliance headaches for affected individuals receiving loans from overseas companies where those exemptions do not apply.
- Purchase of Own Shares rules
Where a company purchases its own shares from a shareholder, the part of the payment representing the excess above the amount of capital originally subscribed will ordinarily be treated as a distribution subject to income tax.
The 'Purchase of Own Shares' rules can apply to give the entirety of the payment capital treatment where these shares are in a 'close company' and meet certain other requirements (essentially targeting the rules at a narrow set of arrangements designed to exit long-standing shareholders for commercial reasons).
The rules have historically centred on a subjective question as to whether the buyback has a "trade benefit". The test has been an ongoing source of dispute between taxpayers and HMRC and has created significant uncertainty for shareholders when planning exits.
The government proposes to replace this with more objective mechanical conditions.
- Distributions from non-UK resident companies
Distributions from non-UK resident companies are currently subject to a narrower income tax charge than those from UK resident companies, with only dividends which are not of a capital nature (and certain other payments which can be taxed as miscellaneous income) within scope of charge.
This means that payments which would be taxable distributions in the hands of a UK shareholder (if made by a UK company) may instead be treated as capital receipts if made by a non-UK company.
Whether a distribution is of a capital nature for UK tax purposes is a question determined by case law and based on the legal nature and mechanics of distribution. The proposed changes look to bring certain distributions (including all dividends and other distributions out of the assets of non-resident companies) within the charge to income tax in line with the treatment of equivalent distributions from UK companies.
The government has answered concerns from the private capital industry by indicating that returns on asset managers' co-investment and genuine investment returns in qualifying fund structures will continue to receive capital treatment where that is available under the current rules.
- Modernisation of the Transactions in Securities (TiS) anti-avoidance regime
The government has confirmed that it intends to reform the entire TiS regime to make it clearer and more robust. It is considering bringing the TiS regime within the income tax self-assessment framework, and more detailed proposals are expected to follow in an upcoming technical consultation.
The precise direction of reform in this area remains unclear, however, with consultation respondents divided between the appropriateness of adopting a new principles-based approach or, alternatively, retaining and improving the existing rules (which have been in place since 1960).
Potentially affected individuals should engage with the technical consultation closely.
At this stage, it feels a little disappointing that the government intends to press ahead with such wide-ranging changes. There appears to have been limited regard given to valid concerns expressed by respondents during the policy consultation about the impact of certain of the changes (specifically those in relation to capital rebasing and non-resident company distributions) on inward investment and genuine business transactions.
Some changes will simplify areas of genuine complexity, but others will create uncertainty and add to individuals' compliance burdens. The extent to which the government has taken on board feedback received will become clear as we progress through the technical consultation in 2027, and the draft legislation begins to take shape in advance of coming into effect in April 2028.
For more analysis of this measure, and the implications for businesses, see our commentary: Business Taxes.